Coaching and Title Ix
The Catch-22 Facing Female Coaches
Female coaches face yet another unique and often insurmountable challenge: they are caught in a double bind of competing stereotypes. On the one hand, they are expected to embody “masculine” traits—confidence, assertiveness, and directness—to be respected as effective leaders. On the other hand, they are also expected to display “feminine” traits—nurturing, emotional sensitivity, and warmth—to meet the emotional needs of their athletes.
This impossible balancing act creates a Catch-22:
- If a female coach is too assertive, she is labeled as harsh or unlikable.
- If she is too nurturing, she is perceived as weak or ineffective.
Male coaches are not held to these same conflicting standards. As a result, female coaches are more likely to face complaints, investigations, and terminations, even when their behavior mirrors that of their male colleagues. This systemic bias unfairly punishes women and deters them from pursuing or staying in coaching roles, further perpetuating gender disparities in college athletics.
Gender Socialization
From a young age, societal norms shape how boys and girls are taught to express themselves. This phenomenon, known as gender socialization, influences behaviors, expectations, and the ways individuals respond to challenges throughout their lives, including in sports.
The Resulting Bias
- This difference in reporting styles has profound implications for female coaches. Coaches of women’s teams often face higher levels of scrutiny and complaints because their athletes are more likely to report perceived emotional risks.
- Administrators often fail to contextualize this disparity, instead viewing complaints as proof of misconduct or failure on the part of female coaches. This leads to increased investigations, sanctions, and terminations, further perpetuating stereotypes about women in leadership roles.
- While male coaches are not directly impacted by stereotypes, they are harmed as the coaching profession is damaged by the continued enabling of bias-driven claims about normal and effective college coaching.
Defending Your Dignity Bold Representation for Bold Change
See What Sets Us Apart
-
Equity for All
Fighting for your rights, we work towards the fundamental equality of every individual.
-
Accountability-Focused
We work to ensure organizations are responsible for creating fair and just workplaces.
-
Employee Advocates
We empower our clients to have their voices heard and their rights protected.
-
Fostering Inclusion
At our core, we drive positive change through education and implicit bias training.
What Is to Be Done?
To combat gender stereotypes in college athletics, bold action is required. Here are some key steps institutions and policymakers must take:
- End Gender Segregation in Coaching Roles
Universities must actively recruit and consider women for coaching positions on men’s teams and ensure that women are equitably represented in coaching women’s teams. - Implement Bias Training and Policy Reforms
Administrators, athletes, and hiring committees should undergo training to recognize and mitigate the effects of gender stereotypes in decision-making. - Standardize Complaint and Investigation Processes
Establish unbiased protocols for collecting and evaluating athlete concerns, ensuring that decisions are based on evidence rather than stereotypes. - Strengthen Enforcement of Title VII and Title IX
Regulatory bodies must hold institutions accountable for discriminatory practices, imposing consequences for systemic violations of federal anti-discrimination laws.
By taking these steps, institutions can create an environment where female coaches are judged on their qualifications and performance, not their gender.
Contact us today to get started with our team and to schedule your initial consultation. We are here to help you fight for your rights.
-
"No One I'd Recommend More"
We came to Jill Zwagerman and were met with compassion, calm, intelligence and a fierce dedication to legally hold our offenders accountable. Jill walked us through the entire process leading us with confidence and compence.- Jodi S. -
"They Speak My Language"
Tom Newkirk and his firm are experts on the state of college athletics and the type of bias that coaches and especially female coaches deal with on daily bases. They speak a language that anyone can understand.- Petra M.